From the employee-owners of Gardener's Supply

Best Bread and Butter Pickles

Bread and butter pickles

This year’s first batch of bread and butter pickles.

My mom makes the best bread and butter pickles. I bet you think your mom makes the best bread and butter pickles, too. So is it about the cucumbers, the brine or the mom?

I asked around the office and looked around a bit online, and am I’m convinced it’s all about the mom. That’s because there’s so little variation in bread and butter pickle recipes. They all include the same five things in roughly the same proportions:

Cucumbers and Onions

Relatively thin rounds of sliced cucumbers and sliced onions. I usually peel my cukes but that’s up to you.


Plain white vinegar is standard. Some recipes call for blending it with apple cider vinegar.


Salting the cucumbers draws out the their natural juices so they’ll be eager to absorb the brine. This step requires a shocking amount of salt, but most of it gets poured off. Be sure to use kosher or pickling salt, not standard table salt


You may be surprised by the large amount of sugar in these recipes. You can experiment with cutting it back a bit, but I doubt your mom would have done that.


Mustard seeds, celery seeds and turmeric are standard. Don’t use that old stuff in your spice drawer; your homegrown pickles deserve better. Some people add stick cinnamon, whole cloves and whole allspice. Did your mom do that?

Here’s the recipe my mom and I use. It’s from that oldy-but-goodie book published in the mid-70s, Putting Food By, by Ruth Hertzberg, Janet Greene and Beatrice Vaughan. If you’re not up for the canning part, just let the jars cool and then keep them in your refrigerator. I don’t have room in my refrigerator for more than one jar of pickles at a time, so I can my pickles so they can be stored on a shelf in the pantry.

A couple notes. I like to use the milder red or white onions rather than yellow onions. I also like to add a few red pepper slices to each jar for color (see photo, above).

Bread-and-Butter Pickles
from Putting Food By

  • 6 lbs medium cucumbers
  • 1 1/2 cups sliced onions
  • 1 large garlic cloves, left whole
  • 1/3 cup salt
  • 2 trays of ice cubes
  • 4 1/2 cups white sugar
  • 1 1/2 tsp turmeric
  • 1 1/2 tsp celery seed
  • 2 tbsp mustard seed
  • 3 cups white vinegar

Wash the cucumbers thoroughly; drain; cut unpeeled cucumbers into 1/4-inch slices. In a large bowl, combine the cucumber slices, onion, garlic and salt; cover with the ice, mix thoroughly and let stand for 3 hours. Drain off the liquid and remove the garlic. In a large pot, combine the sugar, spices and vinegar and heat just to a boil. Add the cucumber and onion slices; simmer together 10 minutes. Pack loosely in clean, hot pint jars, leaving 1/2 inch of headroom; remove air bubbles. Adjust lids; process in a boiling-water bath (212 degrees F.) for 10 minutes. Remove. Cool. Makes 7 pints.

If you’re not an experienced pickle-maker, you might want to check out the B&B pickle recipe on Simply Recipes as there are good step-by-step photos that give you an idea what to expect at each stage.

Have your own special tweaks on this traditional homemade condiment? Leave a recipe or comment below.


  1. Anonymous
    July 28, 2010    

    We use apple cider vinegar instead of white. And on half of the jars we place 2 broken chile peppers with seeds in each jar then fill them.

  2. Anonymous
    July 28, 2010    

    Have been pickling for a long time, lost my cukes, so used zucchini, a little softer but great pickles.
    Redwood Turtle

  3. July 28, 2010    

    I absolutely love bread and butter pickles. Yummy. I love to put red pepper flakes for a pinch of spice.

  4. Anonymous
    July 28, 2010    

    Soak in pickling lime overnight up to 24 hours. Rinse thoroughly. Pickle as usual, makes for extra crunchy and crisp pickles. Eliminates the soaking in salt and or ice water.

    • Shellie
      September 13, 2016    

      How much pickling lime do you use?

  5. Jack Kramer
    July 28, 2010    

    Any reason why white vinegar is used in the recipe? I’ve always used cider vinegar called-for in the recipe I got from a neighbor.

  6. July 28, 2010    

    Cider vinegar works fine. It does add its own flavor to the recipe, whereas white vinegar is more flavorless.

  7. January 21, 2011    

    I think this is a pretty nice idea. I would love to make some since I am not really busy.

  8. Eddie
    June 21, 2013    

    Good recipe, mine is just a little different. This year I am trying Ball’s Pickle Crisp instead of salt or lime, so I’ll see how good it works.

    • Robin Malsack
      September 14, 2016    

      Ball pickle crisp works quite well. I have been using it for 3 years now. Do NOT use in PLACE of salt. You only use 1/8 tsp per pint, or 1/4 tsp per quart. Very little sodium is added to the finished product.

  9. sandra
    August 12, 2016    

    I have found you must use bottled water and not water softened water esp. when making dill pickles

  10. Anne M Ross
    September 13, 2016    

    Would the lime crisp up zucchini slices if soaked over night?

  11. Allison L Friedman
    September 13, 2016    

    I’m not fond of sweet pickles. Can the sugar be eliminated or will that affect the fermentation?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Garden-tested tools, innovations and know-how for every gardener